I just finished Three and Out: Rich Rodriguez and the Michigan Wolverines in the Crucible of College Football by John U Bacon.
Shocked. That was how I felt the night of Dec. 1 2007. All we (“we” is the football team of my beloved West Virginia University) had to do was beat what seemed to be a clearly inferior opponent. Win this game against arch-rival Pitt and we would be playing in the National Championship game.
We lost.
It was, in a word, devastating; truly surreal. Sleepless nights followed. I kept playing the game in my head over and over again and thinking of all that we could have done to win. So, when our then-Coach Rich Rodriguez called it quits a few days later and headed to coach at the University of Michigan, it capped what had to be one of the worst weeks in Mountaineer athletics.
After reading Bacon’s book, I have a better understanding of why he left and, a few years removed from all the severe, abject and debilitating pain, I can see his point. The lack of support Rich Rod received from both the higher ups in the athletic department and school itself was painful. Michigan’s courtship and WVU’s response seemed to culminate in a showdown between Rod and school president Mike Garrison (a man who lasted less than a year after being installed by former Governor Joe Manchin.) During this meeting, which Garrison attended in his pajamas, the president basically said the following: “You’ve got a tough decision to make” and “take it or leave it.” Despite this stunningly shrewd negotiation tactic, he failed to keep Rich Rod on board.
My friends gave me nine shades of hell for defending Rod at the time he left but I said it then and I’ll say it now – he was put into a corner by the good ol boys and rather than back down, he came out swinging.
I hated that he left and I can see why some would think he betrayed the state and the school, but I respect his reasoning behind it. Garrison and those responsible for his installation saw Rich Rod as a threat, plain and simple. Even the biggest Rich Rod hater could look over his want list and think “this doesn’t seem out of line.” If you do, what do you think Nick Saben gets? Or Chip Kelly? What about Urban Meyer or Les Miles? Do you think the AD is going to cringe when he asks for “better pay for his assistants?” What about this world beater – “free passes for high school coaches?” How about this pound of flesh – “an all-access pass for his wife?” These slight demands were too much for WVU’s brain trust.
It’s telling that Bacon was able to interview so many for this book and most everyone at Michigan answered his questions, but Manchin, Garrison and Pastilong refused to talk to him. To this day, I’m still infuriated by everything surrounding this situation. Rich Rod wanted to win and take West Virginia football to the very top of intercollegiate athletics. I have no doubt he would have done just that.
I’ll go back to this point one last time, but when Rich Rod asked Garrison “Where do you want to take this program,” all he could respond was “take it or leave it.” Are we only getting one side of the story? Yes. Has Garrison ever bothered to refute this or even discuss his version of what happened that night? No. Every fan of WVU football paid for that lack of leadership for three years (save the Fiesta Bowl, a game that was called by Rich Rod’s offensive coordinator).
If he thought things would be better in Ann Arbor, he was mistaken. According to the book, the Michigan football family has a lot of factions, but legendary coach Bo Schembechler was able to keep everyone in line. After he died, that family lost their father. From the day he arrived at UofM, a vocal and powerful part of that family was always against him, including the Detroit Free Press, which, it could be argued (and Bacon does) served up hit piece after hit piece which relied on innuendo and whispers over old-fashioned, shoe leather reporting.
Here’s one example of the way Rich Rod never fit in – a higher up at the school sent word that Rich Rod needed to watch his language. When he tried to think of what profane word or term he used at a public gathering, he was told the misstep was the word “ain’t.” In West Virginia, using ain’t is a sign of solidarity, the kind of grammatical rebellion that goes right along with Montani Sempre Liberi. Rich Rod was not a “Michigan Man.” There was friction with former coach Lloyd Carr and Rich Rod had frosty relationship with a number of backers.
His outsider status aside, Rich Rod also failed to embrace much of the tradition. Rather than rely on the tried and true, he thought that winning would take care of it all. And it would have. If he had actually won. Only one winning season at a place like Michigan and three straight loses to Michigan State and Ohio State isn’t going to do the trick.
Part of the problem might be the proud tradition that the school holds so dear. When Nick Saben got to Alabama, the first thing he did was tell anyone who would listen that Bear Bryant isn’t going to win any more games. He maintained that the Crimson Tide isn’t going to beat anyone just because they’re the Crimson Tide He preached from day one that winning meant investment in facilities, coaches, players, everything. The school wisely listened and the results have shown.
Next up is Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro.